7 Short Story Writing Exercises for a Story That Starts Too Early

Spread the love

Your character has an appointment at noon. The appointment will cost her a job, a friendship, or a home. Your first page has her making breakfast.

Breakfast might belong in the story. It depends on what happens while she eats. If she has to choose whether to tell her son they’re losing the apartment, the kitchen may be exactly where the story should begin. If she eats toast and checks the bus schedule, the opening might be making readers wait for the first choice that matters.

These short story writing exercises help you test seven places to begin. Use the same draft for each one. You’ll hear how much the opening changes when you move the reader a few minutes or a few sentences closer to the trouble.

1. Start with the first decision that costs something

Read your first three pages and circle every decision your main character makes. Include the small ones. Who answers a phone? Who puts a letter down unopened? Who chooses where to sit?

Now look for a decision that closes off an option. That’s a strong place to try starting.

Take Ada, who plans to hand over the keys to her late father’s repair shop. In an early draft, she takes the bus, walks past the shops she remembers from childhood, and arrives at her father’s door. The first difficult choice comes when she sees a former customer with a dead radio and says she can fix it.

Try this opening.

“Come back at five,” Ada told the man with the radio. The new tenant was due for the keys at four.

Ada has committed herself to two incompatible promises. Readers can follow that problem before they know any family history.

Try it. Lift the decision out of your draft. Write a first paragraph with the character’s choice in the first two sentences. Add one detail that shows what the choice puts at risk. Then ask what the reader needs to know to understand the consequence. Put that information within reach.

2. Begin one beat before the interruption

A quiet opening can hold attention when it gives the reader a clear thing to watch for. Start with a simple plan already in motion. Interrupt it before the reader settles into the routine.

Ada had one key left to label when someone knocked on the glass. She slid the envelope under the till. At this hour, her father would have let a customer in.

The key, envelope, and clock give the reader a picture of Ada’s task. The knock interrupts that task. The final sentence gives her a reason to hesitate that belongs to this shop.

See also  Word Counter : Count Words, Characters and More

Try it. Identify the first event in your draft that sends the character in a new direction. Write one or two sentences immediately before it. Give the character a small task with an obvious endpoint. Let the interruption arrive before they finish.

If the scene begins three hours before the interruption, ask what those three hours give the reader. Try starting thirty seconds before it. Then read both versions and see whether you miss anything specific from the earlier pages.

3. Move the first uncomfortable line of dialogue to the top

Find the first sentence someone says that makes another character want to leave, lie, or change the subject. Good candidates include a request the listener can’t easily refuse, an accusation that sounds polite, or a remark that exposes something previously kept quiet.

“Your father told me you could fix anything,” the man said.

Ada looked for a plug on the radio. “How long ago did he tell you that?”

The first line puts pressure on Ada. The second gives her something to do with her hands and a reason to ask a question. We begin to sense that the father’s confidence might be news to her.

Try it. Pull a line of dialogue from deeper in your draft and put it first. For the next line, write a brief physical response. Give the reader one concrete detail about where the people are or what stands between them.

Read it to somebody who hasn’t seen your draft. Ask who wants something in the exchange and what they appear to want. If the reader can name the immediate request, you have room to hold back deeper reasons.

4. Open after the event and show its first consequence

Some drafts spend a page dramatizing an event whose aftermath holds the real story. Consider a missed train. If the story is about what happens when a woman must ask her estranged sister for a lift, the opening can begin with her already holding the phone.

For Ada, suppose the relevant event is a call from the new tenant moving the handover earlier. The reader can enter after that call.

Ada wrote TWO O’CLOCK on the envelope and pushed the half-open radio away. The man had paid for the repair in advance. She could see his notes through the paper.

The change of time matters because of what Ada must now do. The money gives the reader a second fact to hold onto. We can find out who changed the appointment when Ada needs to act on it.

Try it. Put a mark beside the event you originally used to open the story. Write the first thing your character does after it. Draft a paragraph around that action, using one clue about what just happened. See whether you need a short follow-up sentence to orient the reader.

See also  25 Poetry Prompts from One Memorable Line

A consequence can be small enough to miss in an outline. Someone takes their name off a group chat. Someone moves a chair before the guest arrives. Those actions work when the reader knows enough to wonder why.

5. Start with an object that has to change hands

A possession can carry exposition while giving the characters something to do. Pick an object whose ownership matters by the end. Think of a borrowed coat, a spare key, a returned photograph, or an envelope someone is trying to pass back.

The new tenant wanted both keys. Ada had one in the envelope and the other in a pocket she’d sewn into her father’s apron.

There’s a practical question on the page. Why is she hanging on to the second key? The apron gives the reader a little history while Ada avoids handing it over.

Try it. Choose an object that appears in the middle or at the end of your story. Put it in someone’s hand in the first paragraph. Write a scene in which a second person wants it. Give the two people different reasons to care about it.

Revise one sentence so the object’s condition shows something about the past. A smooth key has seen years of use. A key still carrying its hardware-store tag suggests a different story. Give the reader a detail they can use before you explain how the object got there.

6. Start twice and move one essential fact

Sometimes a draft feels slow because it opens with information readers genuinely need. Cutting the entire first page leaves the story confusing. In that case, keep the information and change when it arrives.

Suppose the original first page says that Ada’s father used to fix a customer’s radio without charging him. That detail matters when Ada quotes a price. It can surface in the dialogue.

“How much do I owe you?” the man asked.

Ada named a price. He nodded, looking past her for somebody who wasn’t there.

“Your father used to put mine on the shelf with the paid ones.”

Now the reader learns about the father’s habit at the moment it complicates Ada’s transaction.

Try it. Draft two openings. In the first, keep the essential background in the first paragraph. In the second, begin with action and move the information to the moment someone needs it. Read each version and mark the first point at which you have a clear reason to keep going.

See also  30 Last Line Writing Prompts for Powerful Endings

To decide which facts count as essential, ask a reader what confused them first. If they want to know why Ada is at the shop before following the exchange, give them half a sentence about handing over the keys. Save the finer details for the scene that puts them to use.

7. Cut to the first sentence that could only belong to your story

Look at your first page. Put a mark beside any sentence that could open a dozen unrelated stories. A character wakes up. The weather is bad. Someone has a bad feeling. Those lines may be doing useful work later in the draft. As an opening, they can delay the first detail that makes your story recognizable.

Start with a sentence that shows what makes this place, decision, or person particular.

On the back of every radio he fixed, Ada’s father used to write the date in nail polish. Ada had two hours to decide whether to do the same.

The nail polish gives us something unexpected to picture. The time limit gives Ada a task she must face in the present. The combination makes sense in this story because the repaired radio and the handover are already pulling against each other.

Try it. Select the most specific sentence on your first three pages. Put it at the top of a blank page and write two sentences after it. Use the first to show who is there. Use the second to give that person an immediate problem. Read the three lines aloud and see which part deserves the most space.

Pick an opening by reading past it

Choose two versions and read a page of the story after each. An opening can sound excellent by itself and lead straight into a long detour. Compare where each version leaves the character by the bottom of page one. Does the reader understand what they’re after? Is there a reason it matters today? Has the scene moved since the opening line?

For Ada, the promise to repair the radio creates a problem she has to solve right away. The nail-polish detail starts with the father’s presence in the shop and opens a question about what Ada will carry forward. I’d choose the first if the story builds toward the handover and the second if it builds toward Ada’s decision about the work itself.

Do one last pass for details you cut but still love. Put them in a separate document. Then move back only the details your chosen scene can use. The next page should feel like a continuation of the story you just started.


Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top