A short story can have a good beginning and a clear ending and still lose its way between them. Your character knows what they want, but the scenes in the middle keep giving them chances to want it without having to do anything new. A conversation ends with another conversation scheduled. A search uncovers a clue that sends the character back to a place they’ve already been.
These seven short story writing exercises help you revise that middle. Each one changes something your character can do. We’ll use a story about Feyi, who plans to record her grandmother playing a song before the family’s upright piano is moved out on Saturday. The opening and ending are easy to picture. In the middle, Feyi keeps asking when they can record, and her grandmother keeps saying there will be time.
Choose a scene in your own draft where you find yourself repeating a question or moving someone from one place to another. Write down what they could do before the scene begins. When you finish an exercise, see whether they still have all those choices.
1. Close off the easiest option
Feyi plans to bring her phone over on Friday and ask her grandmother to play. On Thursday, the movers call to say they have another job and can collect the piano only at seven the next morning. Feyi can accept the time or lose the help she has already arranged. Her quiet plan for Friday afternoon is gone.
Find the thing your character has been expecting to do next. Remove it for an ordinary reason that belongs in the story. The person they wanted to ask has gone to work. The key is in the coat they lent someone. The neighbor who usually gives them a ride has made another plan.
Write the first thing your character tries with the easy option gone. Feyi might go to her grandmother’s house that evening, when the rest of the family will be there. That change gives the scene new people and a new reason to choose her words carefully. Think about which of those details you can use before you invent another obstacle.
2. Let another person act on a different plan
While Feyi waits to record, her cousin puts the piano bench by the front door for the charity shop to collect. The bench was promised separately, and he believes his job is to make it easy to carry out. He has no reason to know that their grandmother keeps the sheet music beneath its lid.
Give another character one task they can finish without permission from the protagonist. Then let them do it. Your side character might lend a coat, throw out an old timetable, or tell a friend where they should meet. The action can be helpful from their point of view and can make the main character’s next move harder.
Start your revised scene after the side character has acted. Show the first piece of evidence the protagonist sees, like the clean patch on the floor where the bench was. Give them a reason to talk to the person who moved it. Now the conversation can begin with a specific problem they both have to recognize.
3. Make a success create a second problem
Feyi asks her grandmother to play after supper, and this time her grandmother agrees. Feyi gets the first half of the song on her phone. When she asks to hear the last verse, her grandmother says she never learned it. The person who taught her used to sing that part instead of playing it.
Your character can get what they thought they needed halfway through the story. Give the success an effect they couldn’t predict. A person finds a photograph and realizes someone has written the wrong year on it. Someone wins an argument and discovers that the agreement comes with a responsibility they hadn’t considered.
Write the success in one short paragraph. Then write what the character can see or hear after it that makes the old plan insufficient. Feyi can take a perfectly good recording home. She now has a reason to ask who knew the final verse. That question grows out of what she accomplished, so the success moves the story forward even as it gives her more work.
4. Move a decision onto the page where it has a cost
In one version of the story, Feyi tells her cousin she will ask their grandmother again later. She thinks about whether to do it and eventually walks upstairs. The middle can feel sharper if deciding to ask requires Feyi to use something she might want to keep. She has already said she will help her cousin carry boxes upstairs. Asking for ten minutes alone with their grandmother means asking him to work without her or explain why the boxes aren’t ready.
Find a decision your draft leaves inside the character’s thoughts. Put another person in the room who can reasonably ask for an answer. Give both answers a cost you can see. One could leave somebody carrying a box alone. The other could leave an important question unanswered until the person who knows the answer has to go home.
Write the line in which the character chooses. Follow it with what the other person does in response. The scene gets somewhere when the decision changes a relationship, sets a task in motion, or makes a promise harder to keep.
5. Reveal a fact that changes the question
Feyi thinks her grandmother is putting off the recording because she dislikes being heard. Then she discovers a cassette labeled with the song’s title and the date of a family dinner. Her grandmother is already on tape. What Feyi wants to know now is why nobody in the family remembers hearing it.
Look at the question the reader has been carrying from the beginning. Write down one fact that would change its direction. Give that fact to the character while they can still do something with it. A receipt may turn “Where did she go?” into “Why did she come back a day early?” A message can turn “Will he find out?” into “How long has he known?”
Read the scene before and after the discovery. The earlier one should make the new detail recognizable. The later one should show the character pursuing something they had no reason to pursue before. If they continue with the old plan anyway, give them a clear reason to keep it.
6. Put two errands in the same room
Feyi’s first plan is to record the song in the sitting room. Her uncle’s plan is to measure the door so the movers know whether the piano fits through it. In the early draft, each errand gets a separate scene. Put them together. Feyi needs the room quiet while her uncle needs to pull the piano away from the wall and see what is behind it. He will be ready to go as soon as he writes down three numbers.
Pick two scenes in the middle that happen near each other. Name the task that takes place in each and the person who wants it finished. Bring both into one room. Give each task a reason to happen now, and see what the people are willing to negotiate.
The combination can show you how to revise two thin scenes at once. Feyi might offer to hold one end of the measuring tape if the others give her the room afterward. That deal creates a new expectation readers can watch the family keep or break.
7. Make the next move belong to the protagonist
When a middle drags, check who has been making things happen. Feyi can spend several scenes hearing that the movers have called, that her cousin has moved the bench, and that her grandmother has other plans. Give her a move someone else has to respond to. She could bring the cassette player downstairs, put it on the piano, and ask her grandmother to listen to one minute of the recording with her.
Count the decisions in your last two scenes. If your main character has only answered calls, agreed to suggestions, or arrived where someone told them to go, write one action they can initiate. It can be quiet. They can send a photograph, change a room reservation, or carry a chair to the door. Give someone else a reason to respond.
Write that response before you return to the opening. The grandmother could sit down and listen, or she could ask Feyi to turn it off after two notes. Either gives the next scene a direction because Feyi did something that made a response necessary.
Check what can happen after the revised scene
Put the revised scene between the two it has to connect. Read the last paragraph of the scene before it and the first paragraph of the scene after it. Write what somebody can do at each point. If the answers are the same, look for a chance to move a deadline, reveal a useful fact, or make a choice stick.
Next, check whether the middle still points toward an ending you want to write. Feyi’s best ending might be a recording of the complete song. After experimenting, you might prefer a scene where her grandmother names the singer whose voice is missing. A stronger middle can show you that the ending needs to follow a different question.
Save one small instruction for your next session. “Have Feyi turn the cassette over while her grandmother is there” is enough. When you open the draft tomorrow, you can begin with an action and find out what somebody does in answer.
