Buildwriting

A little inspiration to write.

Get poetry and short prose prompts plus practical tips to help you start writing.

Join the newsletter
Leave Page One for Later

8 Short Story Writing Exercises for Writers Who Keep Polishing the First Paragraph

Spread the love

The first paragraph is easy to find and easy to fix. You open the document, spot a word you can improve, and make the sentence a little smoother. Twenty minutes later, you have a better paragraph and the same unfinished story.

These eight short story writing exercises give you somewhere else to begin. They take you into the middle and ending, where a revision can change what the story is about or what a character decides. Once those parts are clearer, you can return to the opening with a better idea of what the first paragraph needs to do.

We’ll use a draft about Dara, who has agreed to help her brother empty their grandmother’s flat before a new tenant moves in. She wants to keep the kitchen table. Her brother has already told a neighbor she can have it. Dara has rewritten the paragraph about climbing the stairs four times. The argument about the table still ends with both siblings giving up and going home.

1. Put a temporary fence around the opening

Copy the first paragraph into a separate note. Underneath, list the things you want to change about it. Keep the list short. You might want a clearer setting or a first line that sounds more like the narrator. Close the note and open the draft at page two.

Now find the first complete exchange between your main characters. Read until somebody does something they had a choice about. If you get to the end of the scene without finding that moment, write one. Dara could put a chair on the table to stop her brother from dragging it toward the door. Her brother could call the neighbor while Dara is still looking for the words to object.

Keeping a record of the opening issues helps you leave them alone for a while. You can come back to them after you’ve made a change that gives the opening a clearer destination.

2. Write what changes at the end of each scene

On a blank page, list your scenes in order. Beside each, write what is different when the scene ends. “Dara and her brother talk in the kitchen” names the activity. “Dara learns the neighbor has already borrowed a van” names a change. It suggests a reason she will have to act soon.

Use one sentence per scene. Look for two neighboring entries that produce the same change. If Dara learns twice that the neighbor plans to take the table, one conversation may need a different outcome. Perhaps the second person can tell Dara why the neighbor specifically wants this table and who offered it.

See also  7 Writing Exercises to Rescue an Unfinished Short Story From Your Notes App

Pick the scene with the weakest change and write only its last three lines. Give somebody a piece of knowledge or a new obligation they didn’t have on the way in. Then revise the scene so those lines follow from something a person did.

3. Put the hardest conversation on a separate page

Find the exchange you keep postponing. It may be the conversation your characters have been working around for five pages. In Dara’s draft, she has complained about the size of the van and the width of the stairs. She has never told her brother she wants the table.

Write the exchange by itself. Start with the first clear sentence somebody could say. “I was going to take it home,” Dara says. Her brother can ask where she’ll put it. That question might make her realize she has already measured a space he didn’t know she was saving.

Once you’ve written a workable exchange, look at the surrounding scenes. Which ones make this conversation harder or give it a consequence? Put those to work. If one exists only to delay a sentence the reader is ready to hear, try bringing the conversation forward.

4. Follow one object from the middle to the end

Pick an object a character handles halfway through the draft. Write down who has it, who thinks they own it, and where it ends up. There might be three different answers. A key someone agrees to lend can turn into a key nobody wants to return.

For Dara, try tracking the screwdriver her brother brings to take the table apart. She uses it to tighten a loose handle on a cupboard. The neighbor later has to borrow it to remove the table legs. By the end, Dara can choose who she hands it to. That handoff gives her a small action with a meaning the earlier scenes have prepared.

Check each appearance of the object. Does somebody do something with it they couldn’t do before? Does it make a decision easier to see? Keep the appearances that change what happens. You only need enough continuity for the reader to notice the handoff.

5. Read backward from the last choice

Start with the final page. Circle the last thing a person does that could have gone another way. Read back until you find the moment the person first had a reason to make that choice. The distance between the two spots can tell you where to revise.

See also  How to Turn an Ordinary Moment Into a Short Story (in 10 Minutes)

Suppose Dara helps the neighbor lift the table into the van. If nothing earlier shows why Dara would change her mind, the ending may feel like a decision made for her. Put one useful event in the middle. The neighbor could bring a bolt from a chair she hopes will fit beneath the table. Dara can recognize it from a set her grandmother gave away years ago. The table has somewhere specific to go.

Try writing two earlier moments that would make your last choice possible. Keep the one that also gives another character a reason to act. An ending has more room to feel earned when the middle has already given several people something to do.

6. Try a different order before rewriting sentences

Take a scene from the middle and give it a one-line label, such as “The neighbor measures the table.” Do the same for the scene before and after it. Put those three labels in a different order. Think through what each person would know when the first scene starts.

If the neighbor measures the table before Dara hears about the promise, Dara and the reader can find out together. If the measurement happens after the argument, it could show Dara how thoroughly the neighbor has imagined taking the table home. The same action can work differently depending on when the reader sees it.

Try the new order in a copy of your draft. Write only the transitions you need. Then check the sequence for a simple chain of action and response. Ideally someone does something in one scene that gives another person a reason to act in the next. Choose the order that makes that chain easiest to follow.

7. Draft one consequence beyond the ending

Write a short scene set the morning after your current ending. Give the main character a regular job to do: make tea, answer a text, or carry out the rubbish. Show how the ending changes one step in that routine.

Imagine Dara turning into her kitchen with a cup and finding there is still nowhere to set it down. Or imagine the neighbor inviting her over and pulling out a chair under the old table. If one of those moments feels more alive than your current last page, look at the choice that made it possible. You may need to show more of that choice in the story.

See also  7 Writing Exercises to Turn One Memory Into a Poem, Short Story, or Personal Essay

The extra scene can stay in your notes. Its job is to show you whether the ending creates a change someone can live with. Once you can picture that change, return to your last paragraph and see how much of it the reader could imagine from there.

8. Give the opening a new assignment

Reopen the note with your first paragraph. Read it once alongside the ending you have now. List two facts the reader needs early and one question you’d like them to carry into the next page. Use that list to revise the opening in one pass.

If Dara’s story now turns on giving the table away, she might enter the flat and set her tape measure on it while she takes off her coat. We see what she came to do before either sibling says it aloud. The stairs can stay if climbing them tells us something the table cannot, such as how much work is involved in getting a heavy piece of furniture out of the building.

Read the opening through the end of the first scene. Make the smallest change that gets the reader into the action you now have. When you can see what they’re waiting to find out, give the paragraph a rest.

Try these in one revision session

If you have half an hour, spend five minutes listing the changes in your scenes. Pick the spot where the fewest things change and spend fifteen minutes drafting a stronger exchange or action. Use the final ten minutes to read what comes before and after it. This gives you a way to tell whether the revision should affect another part of the story.

Leave a note at the exact point where you want to resume. “Have Dara ask who measured the van” is easier to pick up tomorrow than “fix middle.” If you found a problem with the opening, write what the opening needs to prepare the reader for. The next time you edit that paragraph, you’ll have somewhere to go after it.


Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top